Citizens United Chart Keys

1. The Advance Group was Fined by the CFB for working for Councilmembers Levine and Cumbo at the same time they were working under a hidden name for the UFT PAC United for the Future  

2, 3.    All the council candidate that Red Horse worked for got paid mailing from the UFT’s United for the Future PAC that Red Horse Also Worked for

4.5.    Berlin Rosen worked for the UFT the same time that they ran several council candidates funding by the UFT’s PAC United for the Future. 

6. .  In 2009 Berlin Rosen worked for several candidates that got campaign help from Data and Field that the CFB ruled was a illegal campaign arm of the WFP not a private company.  de Blasio also got funded by Data and Field.  

7. The American Federation of Teachers (AFT) donated $350,000 to campaign for one NY PAC  run by  de Blasio aides.  The donation about a month before de Blasio and UFT reached a nine-year contract agreement that approved incremental yearly pay raises totalling 19 percent when compounded.

8        Teachers union paid $370K to fake consultant The United Federation of Teachers' payments to an apparently fictitious consulting firm raises new questions about the Advance Group's actions in the 2013 elections.  

9.      Many credit the $1 million spent by NYCLASS Run by the Advance Group with killing Quinns chances of become mayor in 2014

10.  The Advance Group was Fined by the CFB for working for Councilmembers Levine and Cumbo at the same time they were working for the UFT PAC United for the Future but they did not fine Advance for working for Councilmen Rodríguez or Manhattan BP candidate whose campaigns were also run by the Advance group and funded by NYCLASS PAC who Advance ran

11.  Berlin Rosen worked for the UFT the same time that they ran several candidates funding by the UFT’s PAC United for the Future  It is illegal to coordinate campaigns and PACS

12.  During the 2013 Red Horse work for several candidates as a consultant at the same it worked for the UFT PAC United for the Future.  It is illegal to coordinate campaigns and PACS

13. . Red Horse Works for the follow DAs Brooklyn, Bronx, Staten Island and Manhattan 

14.  The Advance Group PAC NYCLASS did mailing for Council Speaker

Mark-Viverito campaigns at the same time they were illegally work for her to become council speaker

15.  Berlin Rosen was not fined by the CFB Like the Advance Group was for working for the UFT and being a consultant for both the Cumbo and Levine council campaigns

16. United for the Future PAC funded 16 other Council Candidates

 A.  Election lawyer Lawrence Mandelker works for the Mayor’s Campaign for One NY PAC  B.  Mandelker works for both the mayor campaign committee in 2013, 2017   C.  Lawyer Mandelker represented the Advance Group on its Illegal work in the race that made Mark-Viverito the council speaker before the AG, CFB and Conflict Board  D.  The mayor picks half of both CFB and Conflict of Ethics

Board members and the Council Speaker picks the others half.